What show from Seasons 1-5 would you most love to see in Season 10?

We’re deep in the thick of planning for our landmark 10th anniversary season coming up in fall 2025 — so we’re asking you to weigh in and get a bit nostalgic with us! If you had it your way, which show from our first five seasons would you most love to see make a comeback in 2025-26? Dying to catch one of these Good Night standards one more time, or did you miss it the first time around and would love your shot at seeing it anew?

Vote in the poll below, and let us know!